United States District Court, D. Nevada
ORDER re: Doc. # 48
WILLIAM G. COBB, Magistrate Judge.
Before the court is Plaintiff's Motion Identifying Unserved Defendants (3rd)/Motion Ordering Service by Publication. (Doc.# 48.) Plaintiff seeks to effect service by publication upon Defendants Espinoza, Guerrero, Kyker and Volden. He also seeks to substitute "C/O Richard Smith and/or C/O Dennis Stuckey" for the individual his amended complaint names as "Smitty" or "Spivvy" ( id at 2). He similarly seeks to have C/OT Lamar Gibson and/or C/O Timothy Green" substituted for the defendant identified as "Garlet."
Defendants responded to Plaintiff motion. (Doc. # 51.) Although Defendants request this court require Plaintiff to verify his ability to pay for the costs of publication, they do not oppose Plaintiff's request. ( Id., at n.1, p. 2.) However, Defendants object to substituting multiple individual correctional officers in place of "Smitty, Spivvy" or "Garlet." ( Id. )
In Plaintiff's reply memorandum, he states he has a "family friend" who will bear the costs of service by publication. (Doc. # 52 at 1-2.) Plaintiff states the Marshal's return reflects service was not effected on Defendant Volden so he wants the service by publication to extend to him as well.
Plaintiff also states that he is "now confident" that the person he sued as "Spivvy/Smitty" is Richard Smith and submits that Lamar Gibson should be substituted for the person he sued as "Garlet." ( Id., at 2.)
After receipt of Plaintiff's reply memorandum the court instructed Defendants to respond to Plaintiff's contention "Spivvy/Smitty" is Richard Smith and that "Garlet's" name is Lamar Gibson. Doc. # 54.) Defendants filed a sur-reply. (Doc. # 56.) Although Defendants were skeptical about Plaintiff's identification of these two defendants, Defendants did not object to the substitution of Richard Smith and Lamar Gibson as defendants. ( Id. at 2.)
Therefore, the component of Plaintiff's motion (Doc. # 48) which seeks to substitute as defendants Richard Smith, in place of "Smitty or Spivvy, " and Lamar Gibson for "Garlet" is GRANTED.
Defendants' counsel has accepted service of Plaintiff's action on behalf of Lamar Gibson. Defendants' counsel has advised Defendant Richard Smith no longer works for the Nevada Department of Corrections. Mr. Smith's last known address was filed under seal. (Doc. # 58.) If plaintiff wishes to have the U.S. Marshal attempt service on this defendant, he shall follow the instructions contained in this order.
The Clerk shall issue a summons for Richard Smith and send the same to the U.S. Marshal with the address provided under seal (Doc. # 57). The Clerk shall also send one copy of the complaint and one copy of this order to the U.S. Marshal for service on the defendant. The Clerk shall send to plaintiff one USM-285 form. Plaintiff shall have until Monday, November 3, 2014, to complete the USM-285 service form and return it to the U.S. Marshal, 400 South Virginia Street, Room 201, Reno, Nevada 89501.
Plaintiff's motion also seeks to serve Defendants Espinoza, Guerrero, Kyker and Volden by publication. Plaintiff's motion presents a myriad of problems.
Nevada Rule of Civil Procedure 4(e)(1)(i), which the court is to follow for service by publication in a federal action, requires the party seeking service by publication to ...